Become a 5-star prospect in Road to Glory Mode.

Pretty simple. If you play as a QB, RB, or WR it will be easy to earn as long as you play well. Personally I played as a QB with balanced skills so I could long bomb the ball as well as run it a lot. You should easily have a 5* rating by the time you get to the championship game, if not you will surely get it when you win the last game.

Note: The achievement won't unlock until signing day, so don't freak out if it doesn't pop right after you earn your 5th star.