i like the first one because the colours are better, 9/10

Am i right in saying the only difference between the two is curves?

first one because it stands out more 8/10

Those are really good although if I had to pick and use on of the two forum signatures I'd most likely choose the first one. The first one has a lot more vibrance and contrasting included and the render character's hand actually looks like it's arousing from outside the signature which is pretty awesome. It'll look a little better with some sort of text layer included to the left or right hand side. Nonetheless, great job on those signatures. I hope to see more. ;)

I would rather v1. This Criticism is based on v1 only. First I would like to say that the render isn't very well cut out and there is still an outline on the render, also I see flames in the bottom right of the signature, and they are quite LQ, and would look better if they were of better quality. The image has nice depth, the text placement is nice and isn't too noticeable. 8/10

That's some sick shiz you got going on there :trollin:



:nyancat: Run before he invades you!

I personally would say the first one.
BTW Nice post amount (1337)

-Clean- wrote I would rather v1. This Criticism is based on v1 only. First I would like to say that the render isn't very well cut out and there is still an outline on the render, also I see flames in the bottom right of the signature, and they are quite LQ, and would look better if they were of better quality. The image has nice depth, the text placement is nice and isn't too noticeable. 8/10

Thanks for feedback and i dont render my own things i suck at it but ll try to clean it up man

thanks

uzi wrote Those are really good although if I had to pick and use on of the two forum signatures I'd most likely choose the first one. The first one has a lot more vibrance and contrasting included and the render character's hand actually looks like it's arousing from outside the signature which is pretty awesome. It'll look a little better with some sort of text layer included to the left or right hand side. Nonetheless, great job on those signatures. I hope to see more. ;)

Thanks for the feedback man its always great t hear from you b/c you always give great feedback
btw about the hand it almost looks 3D and never noticed that