great effect and use of shading.....9/10

Cod_4_R2R_ModMenu wrote great effect and use of shading.....9/10

why thank you sir

It's alright and the idea is amazing but there's a couple of issues with it.
For starters the water looks unreal, it's hard to get water edits looking correct it's one of the hardest things out there so I can't expect you to get that correct.
Next, it's the mark on the right, it's weird what's it doing there? Same thing for the vertical line at the top.
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

EDIT:
Also, the perspective of the water is wrong, I see now you took it from looking slightly down on a waterfall, this image is eye level. In order to get the right image you'd need to get an eye level picture of a waterfall.

Concept wrote It's alright and the idea is amazing but there's a couple of issues with it.
For starters the water looks unreal, it's hard to get water edits looking correct it's one of the hardest things out there so I can't expect you to get that correct.
Next, it's the mark on the right, it's weird what's it doing there? Same thing for the vertical line at the top.
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]
[ Register or Signin to view external links. ]

EDIT:
Also, the perspective of the water is wrong, I see now you took it from looking slightly down on a waterfall, this image is eye level. In order to get the right image you'd need to get an eye level picture of a waterfall.

i guess i missed a few spots while cleaning it up a bit here let me go back and clean it up a lil more my bad XD
edit:and as for the waterfall yes i know i couldnt find any of the right types that i wanted so i just took some diffrent ones and combined them to make one ..and also i would like to thank you your the first person to give me real criticism

there we go updated and cleaned up

I preferred the water placement on the first one, now you have random blobs of blue in there. Perspective might be a little better not too sure o.O and you still have that vertical line at the top.

Concept wrote I preferred the water placement on the first one, now you have random blobs of blue in there. Perspective might be a little better not too sure o.O and you still have that vertical line at the top.

[ Register or Signin to view external links. ] ok last update
what i did was take out all the lil spots that you noticed now it is clean and i also darkend around the edges of the hand to give it more of a shadow look to it and i tryed to make it also look like water was going through the cracks of the hand tell me what you think now plz XD