I don't get what's wrong about this. It's a persons taste in music. So what if people only like the one good song a band has, it's not stopping you from liking other songs that they don't.

I for one have tons of singles on my itunes but never care if there is only one song from that artist on my phone.

It's a persons taste in music

Exactly the same feeling!

I like Love Coldplay (No homo) and everyones favorite song is always Paradise or Fix You... i mean yeah they are good songs but there are 73 (at least) other songs by Coldplay.

Been to see them live.... was so amazing

I agree with ODST, I only like 1 song by Miley Cyrus, does that mean I shouldn't really listen to it?
Or is it only when people say they love a band that gets you annoyed?

For instance, I would be justified in saying I love Breaking Benjamin because I like pretty much all of their songs, but not justified in saying I love Miley because I like Wrecking Ball, but none of her other songs?

I think you're ranting about someone like me TBH. I have a lot of songs by a lot of singers and bands, but I don't gloat about what my fav song is if I have only heard of one song.

Sometimes their most played song is actually their best song.

I think you should move this to "Jokes and Funny Stuff."

That's like getting mad at someone for eating apples, bananas, and pears rather than just apples.
You can have a variety.

bratoonkid wrote For example, "Yeah man I love Coldplay, my favorite song is Paradise.", or "Yeah I love Anberlin, Feel Good Drag is my favorite song ever."
And their iTunes playlist is full of singles, and stuff like that?
Does anyone else feel this way??

There's nothing wrong of this, it's just personal preference of taste. For instance, there's a few music producers out there that I dislike, but there is at least one song I like most of the time.