The Best advice I can give you from experience is... to buy neither. Save your money, trust me. There are other things more important to buy or save up to buy.

Eh, I would just wait until the Xbro one lowers down in price.

elgato the Xbox one cost to much right but it your money you use it how you want

Personally, I would buy the capture card. I have been interested in starting a youtube career. I feel as if I did I would be successful because I took a business strategy class - meaning I would know how to get my videos out there.

I am making good money an hour I don't work many hours a week because I am 15 but in the summer I make over $100 a week I have a truck payed off and I want something for my self.

Like everyone else who comes on TTG for advice on what to do with their money, I'm gonna give you the same advice I give them.

If you have to come on TTG to ask us what you should do with your money, you obviously don't need those. Because if you really wanted it or needed it you would buy what you want or need more.

Honestly I was in a simalar fiasco not too long back, I chose the elgato but if you're serious in trickshotting and are well, 'pretty known' or it's something you enjoy choose the elgato. Only choose the XB1 if you feel otherwise or just tempted. I would wait out the XB1 for a while and the elgato is compatible making it more time efficient, for the moment and after the xbox purchase.

aka_Joker wrote I am making good money an hour I don't work many hours a week because I am 15 but in the summer I make over $100 a week I have a truck payed off and I want something for my self.

Where do you work to get that kind of money? o.O

I'd choose the Elgato.

As someone else said, wait for the price of the Xbox One to go down a little and wait for more games.
It really doesn't seem worth it to me right now.