Depends on the game.. For MP games, I would obviously like the the gameplay and online to be smooth and awesome. For SP such as Mass effect, binary domain, I prefer the story over anything else, but gameplay would be next

Well it depending on what genre it is.

I really like a game you can explore and discover things, back stories and different concepts. Boarderlands and halo were pretty big on that, and destiny looks can it's going to as well, so I'm excited to discover their concepts and of course the hidden Easter eggs they will have.

Nice to see people care more about gameplay and story over graphics

DOA wrote Nice to see people care more about gameplay and story over graphics

Graphics aren't everything

I think the most important to me in a game are the graphics, game play and the story line.

Graphics- I'm not too keen on playing games with bad graphics, I'm talking old games or certain indie games etc. I love to have great and not realistic, but very detailed graphics in a game just to make all of the game play feel a lot better. Games such as The Walking Dead where the graphics are cartoony but DESIGNED like this I can play as they're purposely made like this.

Game play- The game play itself has to be great because it just wouldn't be fun to play and the story line is very important to me as when I download games I like to get hooked on the story, games like Watch Dogs for example just wasn't enough for me although the concept of the story line was great.

In single player games it's the story and in multiplayer games it's gameplay