Good idea, but essentially, the sticky should have this idea/have it added over time

edit--there also is some reviews there

Ortho wrote Good idea, but essentially, the sticky should have this idea/have it added over time

True, but let's organize it here. I mean I don't think it would matter if it were merged later on.

Astromods wrote

Ortho wrote Good idea, but essentially, the sticky should have this idea/have it added over time

True, but let's organize it here. I mean I don't think it would matter if it were merged later on.

It would be much more efficient to do stuff like strawpolls & surveys on this kinda thing rather than being muddled up among the comments your better off waiting for the owners of the sticky mate

True, true true. I think it will really benefit this forum though

Astromods wrote

Hello everyone viewing the anime forum here on The Tech Game, Astromods here bringing you a really great topic idea!

Essentially, we should create a topic listing off a large amount of anime, added on to daily, with reviews and other things to help other users find new anime or manga to enjoy!

Of course the reviews must have criteria, just like other reviews on this site have, so that it would be legitimate.

Let's toss around some ideas and make a large community effort for our anime section!

If we decide on certain things, like review criteria, ratings, etc, I will add them to this post to keep track!

We already have a review section on the sticky with the guidelines and criteria on it and i quote:

"Finally! A review section that Ive been overlooking for too long. These reviews will be user oriented from TTG, so if youd like to review an anime to put in this guide, message me (Evigishki) and Ill read over it and most likely put it in, giving the reviewer all credit of course. The requirements to file a review for here are
-MUST have links to shows and any videos cited
-Include anime title in both English and Japanese. Ex. Spice & Wolf/ Ookami to Koushinryou
-Include basic review parameters (sound, animation, plot, etc.)
-Include your TTG username so I can properly give credit.
-Make sure to include episode count and genres
-Rating on a 10 scale "

Having a watch list on this thread is a good idea, but another review section that could potentially be buried under other threads while the sticky is always on top, is quite redundant.

Alright, fair enough, let's just start a watch list then

Astromods wrote Alright, fair enough, let's just start a watch list then

wouldn't this just turn out into people posting mals?
i would assume so because they can post the link and we can see their reviews/list from there

Ortho wrote

Astromods wrote Alright, fair enough, let's just start a watch list then

wouldn't this just turn out into people posting mals?
i would assume so because they can post the link and we can see their reviews/list from there

Yeah, but I think we need to rank anime or something like that, like a TTG Watch list, as a community, not single people

it just sounds like recommendations, which the sticky already has lol.
Plus, you could always contribute to it, as a community.
ie; people rank stuff, but it's essentially recommended