According to the game timer, I've played for 8 hours so far.

What you like about the game: New weapons, being able to craft ammo, factions are nice addition to the game.
What you dislike about the game: Exactly like Fallout 3 in every way, even the same bugs, frame rate issues, etc still exist.
Graphics (1-10): 8 Game looks good from a distance, but up close it's pretty ugly
Gameplay (1-10): 9 Same as Fallout 3, gameplay is great but nothing innovative since FO3.
Overall Rating (Can be a comment or number1-10): So far I would say 8.5-9 It's a great game but being extremely similar to Fallout 3 with no big improvements is a big let down.

it look sooooooooooooooooo sick

First impression: Cinematics were cool, the game looked exactly like FO3 when I got in.
What you like about the game: Hardcore mode, gambling, new weapons, weapon mods, make potions ammo etc
What you dislike about the game: Overwhelmed with quests, the graphics have not been updated, some of the same exact guns from FO3 that havent even gotten a graphical update.
Graphics (1-10): 8
Gameplay (1-10): 8
Overall Rating (Can be a comment or number 1-10): So far it is an 8 for me because I haven't gotten to any of the newer weapons that are decent and I've only found a few weapon mods. I'm sure the main storyline will be sweet and hopefully there are some sweet places to explore.

First impression: Bam, right there that sniper kill was Epic....Looks Pwnage..Is pwnage:)
What you like about the game: Everything, the new skill, modes weapons, factions, perks and MUCH MUCH MORE.
What you dislike about the game: Nothing
Graphics (1-10): 9
Gameplay (1-10): 10
Overall Rating (Can be a comment or number1-10): 100/10

i loved fallout 3 soooooo much so my prediction will be it willbe soo god that ill miss only 3-20 days of school [spoil]jkjkjkjk i would get a serious talkin to if i missed 1 day