I have played Fifa so **** long bro for Bundesliga always **** Naldo. He's got a 85 card, shot power is like over 90, he's hit so many long shots and his pace plus his height is amazing. Boatang is a **** must. Have you ever done slide tackles with him? I literally just spam x when I play him in the back and he somehow always find the ball. An occasional red here or there but it's a game who cares lol. For BPL not sure I hate bpl teams in general on Fifa because all play the same. Go with ligue 1 maybe and spend 30k on both Thiago silva and David Luiz. You'll never get a better combo. Buy trap and your solid on every other position as long it's a strong link.

Your Bundesliga CB are decent but for your BPL remove kompany and use mangala he's a phenomenal defender and way better than kompany.

I know this isn't strictly relevant to what you're asking, though if you're after the best CB duo then you must get Chiellini and Barzagli, both fast strong and tall, Low/High work rates.

That's just a bit of advice anyway.

I'd swap Kompany for Koscienly if you're only choosing between them two players, and I haven't tried Naldo because of a combination of his workrates, jumping and balance

If you're asking for the best defenders though, I have no idea why everyone is suggesting expensive defenders, they're slow, have terrible workrates and only have good defending.

Go with Richards, Okore or Mbemba for BPL

Sokratis and Schar were very reliable CBs for me in the Bundesliga and for the BPL I was content with Mangala and Cahill.