Extras wrote 1. Make it funner then Reach
2. Ressemble the other games
3. No Armor Abilities
4. Old BR
5. Old Halo 1 Magnum
6. Forge
7. Bring back all old maps, and new ones
8. Allow to play as other people (Brute, Grunt, hunter, Soldier, jackal, and all the others)
9. Do not bring 'Killstreaks" in to it
10. Allow old graphics change in game.

I know for a Fact they have Forge Mode in it, they said for themselves at the Halo 4 Panel at HaloFEST..

tazoviney wrote 1. Don't release to many DLC. (cause of dlc achievements make my games look incomplete)
2. Halo 3 1000G in game award. like the katana.
3. Halo 2 dual weapons with majority of guns
4. Don't make Campaign to easy for legendary.
5. Skill level ranking from halo 3
6. Master chief's family information. (Conspiracy from halo wars)
7. No hacks or glitches.
8. A public BETA for the game before release.
9. Forge like other halo's but not one main map only. (getting bored playing online on reach on forge world most of the time)
10. Return the living dead back to the way it was on halo 3. The dark maps i liked. also no Radar as a human.
11. No power ups.
12. Large campaign maps like halo 2.
13. Ability to steal all vehicles in campaign except air vehicles when we don't need it.
14. Since the Spartans are not dead, only missing in battle. How about master chief finds some of them and battle side by side with them.

I agree 100% with your statement

1. Not like Reach
2. Not like ODST
3. Have the story line make sense
4. Bungie should help it would be smart of them
5. New enemy like the flood but worse ( kinda like GOW3 )
6. A difficulty higher than legendary, like Mythic or Forerunner (Pros/ no life only lolz)
7. Achievements give you rewards in-game like the katana or RECON
8. In Multiplayer be able to change from Spartans, Elites, Marines, and Brutes
9. Firefight 2.0
10. Campaign DLC , Firefight DLC , Multiplayer DLC ETC.
11. Offline Mods only Please
12. Ability to instantly post a theater mode video on youtube
13. All weapons with equal power
14. Good Pre-order bonuses
15. Have the update system similar to Black Ops and Fallout: New Vegas
16. Dedicated Servers
This took me 20 Minutes to do lol but this is my wishlist for halo 4 if most of this is not available i am not getting the game.