TTG_Appze wrote STOP trowing that word elite around if you werent elite you wouldent be in the NFL and the only (E Word QB) is tom brady and pyton Manning for the next 10 years

They're all elite(except Matt Cassel :facepalm: lol). But we're saying at NFL standards. It's a comparison to other QBs in the NFL. Of course Tom Brady is elite to someone like Brandon Weeden or John Skelton.

-Kyle-- wrote

TTG_Appze wrote STOP trowing that word elite around if you werent elite you wouldent be in the NFL and the only (E Word QB) is tom brady and pyton Manning for the next 10 years

They're all elite(except Matt Cassel :facepalm: lol). But we're saying at NFL standards. It's a comparison to other QBs in the NFL. Of course Tom Brady is elite to someone like Brandon Weeden or John Skelton.

It's an insult to sports fans in this day and age to still try to make a real issue out of something so pathetically empty. When you argue about whether or not a QB is elite, what you're basically saying to the world is, "I don't have anything to say." Eli Manning? NOT ELITE. Ryan Reynolds? NOT A MOVIE STAR. So cut it out, people. I don't care who your blue chippers are, or who your All Iron award winners are, or who rates five stars on Mikey's QB Star Chart. You are wasting lives going over this shit.

Andrew luck did what we thought he would do and so did RG3. Kevin Kolb does more then what people think he does and at a high level. Its not his fault that his defense isn't helping. Locker is doing the exact same in Tennnessee. Cam Newton had a crappy year this year and I expect RG3 and Kapearnick. Andrew Luck is a good QB Hes close to being a great quarterback but all he needs is another year and he has it.

As much of a Steeler fan that I am, I have to be honest here: Ben is nowhere near Elite. This is my opinion.

He gets hurt to easily. He gets tapped, next thing you know he's on the ground crying. I'll admit, he's taken some shots that wear and tear on his body. But you'll have those as a QB. Its the name of the game: Whoever has the ball is who the defense tries to hit the hardest.

Another reason is he chokes. Or atleast this year he did. OT vs DAL this year, pick, sets up GW FG. The game that was a MUST-WIN vs CIN, pick, sets up GW FG, and knocks us out of playoffs. I can't classify him as an Elite QB. Maybe a Good/Great, but not Elite. Yet, atleast. But also, he's surrounded by young talent in the WR position in Wallace (hopefully), Brown, and Sanders. So maybe as they experience more of the league, he'll progress into Elite-status.

This is just my opinion.

How come eli isn't elite? He has two super bowl rings both from beating Tom Brady and the patriots lol wtf Brady will never get another super bowl ring ever

And also, I really hope Geno goes to a good team. I loved watching him and Austin at WVU.

Kevin Cobb is one of the worst players in the NFL and you think he is great?

You guys really need to look at the TALENT level of the QB and what he has around him. Tom Brady has no Future hall of famers at WR and TE besides Rob. and when he won his 3 super bowls he had no future hall of famers at all. Im a patriots fan and im saying that. Kevin Cobb was a amazing back up for the longest time and he will be amazing one day.

Super_Saiyan wrote You guys really need to look at the TALENT level of the QB and what he has around him. Tom Brady has no Future hall of famers at WR and TE besides Rob. and when he won his 3 super bowls he had no future hall of famers at all. Im a patriots fan and im saying that. Kevin Cobb was a amazing back up for the longest time and he will be amazing one day.

The Patriots didn't rely on an offense for their three Super Bowls if you didn't know. They won with a physical defense with big names such as Law, Milloy, Bruschi, Harrison, McGinest, Warren, Seymour, etc. Brady made some clutch plays, but the Patriots did not rely on their offense the whole way.

Super_Saiyan wrote You guys really need to look at the TALENT level of the QB and what he has around him. Tom Brady has no Future hall of famers at WR and TE besides Rob. and when he won his 3 super bowls he had no future hall of famers at all. Im a patriots fan and im saying that. Kevin Cobb was a amazing back up for the longest time and he will be amazing one day.

or its time for you to loook realistic into qb and fined theres only 2 qbs that will be elite for the next 10 years