Realistically, I think Rocket League or Fallout 4 are the top two. I'm going to go the selfish/biased route though and say Batman: Arkham Knight. I loved that game so much.

Going with Blops 3.
I've only picked up like 3 games out of this selection, Rocket league would be a strong second. MGSV wasn't much to me.
Wouldnt mind trying fallout or jc3.

It's all opinion based which I respect, but in reality it's not the best game which wins these each year, it's the most popular and it's always Call of Duty.

A couple of these games, if not half are a lot better than Black Ops 3, yet they won't stand a chance against the juggernaught (pun intended) of the CoD game. It's pretty stupid, but like I said, it's all about opinion so yep.

People should broaden their horizons a bit.

Even though I haven't played it yet, halo 5.

Black Ops 3 for me.

And it's in the lead!

Why isn't Minecraft on there? It would be top every year ;) :'(

Black Ops 3 fam!

Well okay, but can anybody tell me why there isn't Fifa 16 in this list? :rockedover:

I've gone BOPS3 just as it's such a good game and the revival of COD.

Also very glad FIFA is not on this list.

Halo wrote Even though I haven't played it yet, halo 5.

That is shameful Halo, how could you?

I always hate the GOTY ratings - it's always just fanboys voting for their favourite game, not the one that deserves it.

I mean let's be honest, Call of Duty is nothing special. They've improved this year and it is actually fun to play. There's nothing that makes it game of the year worthy though.

Fallout 4 was a hugely hyped game. It's a brilliant game, don't get me wrong, but I feel like all the hype and fanboy-ism over it will give it unrealistic ratings for the game of the year award.

In my opinion, games such a Rocket League don't deserve game of the year for the lack of actual content it has. Don't think this means I dislike the game, it's one of my favourites to play... It's a very repetitive game though, that's the trouble.

Batman is the one game on the list of nominees that I genuinely feel annoyed about. The game isn't bad but the release on the PC is still fairly broken to this day. You can't say a game is worthy for game of the year when a lot of the audience can't even play the game they paid for back in July!