AdviceIs this a good build?
Posted:

AdviceIs this a good build?Posted:

NastyGamingNation
  • Summer 2019
Status: Offline
Joined: Apr 24, 20168Year Member
Posts: 734
Reputation Power: 274
Status: Offline
Joined: Apr 24, 20168Year Member
Posts: 734
Reputation Power: 274
pcpartpicker.com/list/qgBf8M

I'll be buying all of this rather soon but want to get some opinions on it. I've only built one computer and it's slower then crap now.

But this pc will be for gaming and streaming.

And also doing side projects with game development
#2. Posted:
M9z
  • Vantage
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 10, 20168Year Member
Posts: 884
Reputation Power: 132
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 10, 20168Year Member
Posts: 884
Reputation Power: 132
The average of technical tests I've found is that the differential between the CPU/GPU combo is only around 6% on average so definitely a very small bottleneck and you should be able to stream just perfectly. Intel is known for breaking the charts on single core performance, but a lot of streamers are actually swapping to AMD based systems because of the price to performance ratio they offer while still being very good with multi-tasking.

If you have the budget for this, do it, but I do have to say I don't feel like you're taking full advantage of this board. If you drop the SSD you chose from the equation, and instead opt for m.2 NVME storage, it'll be less wires over all, plus a bit faster. Go for like, a Samsung 970 Pro Plus 250gb for the top slot just below your CPU socket, and then for the m.2 slot below it, stick a 970 Pro Plus 1tb in that one.

As an addition to the m.2's, you can opt to remove the heat spreaders that come with the motherboard, and go for a heatsink instead, heatsinks for those can be as low as 10 bucks each, with color options, and compared to a heat spreader it does affect thermals, I use the heatsink on my boot drive and it stays around 32c, and for my game drive it stays around 43c with the spreader that came with my motherboard. Though this is just if you're like me and prefer the lowest temps possible, because most m.2 manufacturers state that they can operate up to even 70c before throttling speeds on that.

As for power parts though, CPU/GPU you should have no issues as far as I can tell.
#3. Posted:
NastyGamingNation
  • Summer 2019
Status: Offline
Joined: Apr 24, 20168Year Member
Posts: 734
Reputation Power: 274
Status: Offline
Joined: Apr 24, 20168Year Member
Posts: 734
Reputation Power: 274
M9z wrote The average of technical tests I've found is that the differential between the CPU/GPU combo is only around 6% on average so definitely a very small bottleneck and you should be able to stream just perfectly. Intel is known for breaking the charts on single core performance, but a lot of streamers are actually swapping to AMD based systems because of the price to performance ratio they offer while still being very good with multi-tasking.

If you have the budget for this, do it, but I do have to say I don't feel like you're taking full advantage of this board. If you drop the SSD you chose from the equation, and instead opt for m.2 NVME storage, it'll be less wires over all, plus a bit faster. Go for like, a Samsung 970 Pro Plus 250gb for the top slot just below your CPU socket, and then for the m.2 slot below it, stick a 970 Pro Plus 1tb in that one.

As an addition to the m.2's, you can opt to remove the heat spreaders that come with the motherboard, and go for a heatsink instead, heatsinks for those can be as low as 10 bucks each, with color options, and compared to a heat spreader it does affect thermals, I use the heatsink on my boot drive and it stays around 32c, and for my game drive it stays around 43c with the spreader that came with my motherboard. Though this is just if you're like me and prefer the lowest temps possible, because most m.2 manufacturers state that they can operate up to even 70c before throttling speeds on that.

As for power parts though, CPU/GPU you should have no issues as far as I can tell.


Thanks. That helps a lot. I have a AMD Cpu right now and it's a lot of issues for me. That's why I'm looking towards intel. And I could do m.2 storage. I might look around some more at different builds. I'm an I just pm you with my builds I'm thinking of?
#4. Posted:
21
  • Gold Member
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 05, 201311Year Member
Posts: 16,215
Reputation Power: 3087
Motto: Me big smarts. Brainy boy do learns much
Motto: Me big smarts. Brainy boy do learns much
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 05, 201311Year Member
Posts: 16,215
Reputation Power: 3087
Motto: Me big smarts. Brainy boy do learns much
M9z wrote If you drop the SSD you chose from the equation, and instead opt for m.2 NVME storage, it'll be less wires over all, plus a bit faster. Go for like, a Samsung 970 Pro Plus 250gb for the top slot just below your CPU socket, and then for the m.2 slot below it, stick a 970 Pro Plus 1tb in that one.

It would also be significantly more expensive, and likely unnecessary for OP, so it would be a huge waste of money. OP should just take that $300+ and put it towards a better GPU or something, rather than storage he might not even properly utilise.

M9z wrote As an addition to the m.2's, you can opt to remove the heat spreaders that come with the motherboard, and go for a heatsink instead

Heatsink = heat spreader. They're the exact same thing.
IIRC NVMe drives actually operate better once they heat up a little. Obviously, they can overheat, but you don't want NVMe drives to be too low temperature either.


OP - What exactly are you using the system for? What games are you gonna be playing, what are you streaming?
Also, what monitor(s) are you using with this system?
Will you be overclocking?
I'm assuming your budget is $1800/1850 USD??
#5. Posted:
M9z
  • Vantage
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 10, 20168Year Member
Posts: 884
Reputation Power: 132
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 10, 20168Year Member
Posts: 884
Reputation Power: 132
NastyGamingNation wrote
M9z wrote The average of technical tests I've found is that the differential between the CPU/GPU combo is only around 6% on average so definitely a very small bottleneck and you should be able to stream just perfectly. Intel is known for breaking the charts on single core performance, but a lot of streamers are actually swapping to AMD based systems because of the price to performance ratio they offer while still being very good with multi-tasking.

If you have the budget for this, do it, but I do have to say I don't feel like you're taking full advantage of this board. If you drop the SSD you chose from the equation, and instead opt for m.2 NVME storage, it'll be less wires over all, plus a bit faster. Go for like, a Samsung 970 Pro Plus 250gb for the top slot just below your CPU socket, and then for the m.2 slot below it, stick a 970 Pro Plus 1tb in that one.

As an addition to the m.2's, you can opt to remove the heat spreaders that come with the motherboard, and go for a heatsink instead, heatsinks for those can be as low as 10 bucks each, with color options, and compared to a heat spreader it does affect thermals, I use the heatsink on my boot drive and it stays around 32c, and for my game drive it stays around 43c with the spreader that came with my motherboard. Though this is just if you're like me and prefer the lowest temps possible, because most m.2 manufacturers state that they can operate up to even 70c before throttling speeds on that.

As for power parts though, CPU/GPU you should have no issues as far as I can tell.


Thanks. That helps a lot. I have a AMD Cpu right now and it's a lot of issues for me. That's why I'm looking towards intel. And I could do m.2 storage. I might look around some more at different builds. I'm an I just pm you with my builds I'm thinking of?


You can, and if you don't mind me asking, specifically what AMD CPU do you have right now?
#6. Posted:
MrParker
  • Winner!
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 28, 20186Year Member
Posts: 2,123
Reputation Power: 11571
Motto: Read ( The Four Agreements ) , Don't stop educating yourself.
Motto: Read ( The Four Agreements ) , Don't stop educating yourself.
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 28, 20186Year Member
Posts: 2,123
Reputation Power: 11571
Motto: Read ( The Four Agreements ) , Don't stop educating yourself.
Yes your good
#7. Posted:
M9z
  • TTG Master
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 10, 20168Year Member
Posts: 884
Reputation Power: 132
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 10, 20168Year Member
Posts: 884
Reputation Power: 132
21 wrote
M9z wrote If you drop the SSD you chose from the equation, and instead opt for m.2 NVME storage, it'll be less wires over all, plus a bit faster. Go for like, a Samsung 970 Pro Plus 250gb for the top slot just below your CPU socket, and then for the m.2 slot below it, stick a 970 Pro Plus 1tb in that one.

It would also be significantly more expensive, and likely unnecessary for OP, so it would be a huge waste of money. OP should just take that $300+ and put it towards a better GPU or something, rather than storage he might not even properly utilise.

M9z wrote As an addition to the m.2's, you can opt to remove the heat spreaders that come with the motherboard, and go for a heatsink instead

Heatsink = heat spreader. They're the exact same thing.
IIRC NVMe drives actually operate better once they heat up a little. Obviously, they can overheat, but you don't want NVMe drives to be too low temperature either.


OP - What exactly are you using the system for? What games are you gonna be playing, what are you streaming?
Also, what monitor(s) are you using with this system?
Will you be overclocking?
I'm assuming your budget is $1800/1850 USD??


They actually aren't the same thing, heat spreaders do exactly what the name suggests, heatsinks however can be actively cooled by the case airflow and can show a significant change in temps between the two. The gap for my m.2's thermals is around 10c between two of the same models, so it definitely does make a difference, I'm also well aware of m.2's being able to safely operate up to 70c average between manufacturers before throttling, but they can also operate as low at 0c before running into issues there, most people do prefer lower temps overall where they can be achieved, and I'd rather have mine running at 30c with my heatsink instead of 40c with the spreader.

Also, m.2's are as fast as traditional SSD's, you're right there, but NVMe m.2's which this board supports do perform a bit better, and can also help performance on some games like Fallout 4 where storage speed does play a significant part due to it being a port and not that well optimized for PC, even using my NVMe there were a few mods I had to install to further help that particular issue resolve itself.

By all means he can definitely go with a traditional SSD, but I was just throwing my opinion in which is what he made this post for.
#8. Posted:
21
  • PC Master Race
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 05, 201311Year Member
Posts: 16,215
Reputation Power: 3087
Motto: Me big smarts. Brainy boy do learns much
Motto: Me big smarts. Brainy boy do learns much
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 05, 201311Year Member
Posts: 16,215
Reputation Power: 3087
Motto: Me big smarts. Brainy boy do learns much
M9z wrote They actually aren't the same thing, heat spreaders do exactly what the name suggests, heatsinks however can be actively cooled by the case airflow and can show a significant change in temps between the two.

In terms of m.2 SSD "heat spreaders", yes they're the same thing. It's a sheet of metal that pulls heat away from the SSD. "Heat spreaders" can also be "actively cooled by case airflow" so long as it's making proper contact with the heat source.

M9z wrote ]The gap for my m.2's thermals is around 10c between two of the same models, so it definitely does make a difference

Different heat spreaders in different locations, yeah that doesn't surprise me that both drives aren't the exact same temp.

M9z wrote Also, m.2's are as fast as traditional SSD's, you're right there, but NVMe m.2's which this board supports do perform a bit better, and can also help performance on some games like Fallout 4 where storage speed does play a significant part due to it being a port and not that well optimized for PC, even using my NVMe there were a few mods I had to install to further help that particular issue resolve itself.

I didn't say NVMe wasn't better, I said it's a waste of $300+ to go with a 1TB 970 Pro if all OP is using the system for is gaming/streaming. A far cheaper NVMe SSD would perform more than adequately, and the extra money would make far more sense in a better GPU, which WILL actually show a noticeable improvement in performance for OP.
#9. Posted:
M9z
  • Blind Luck
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 10, 20168Year Member
Posts: 884
Reputation Power: 132
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 10, 20168Year Member
Posts: 884
Reputation Power: 132
21 wrote
M9z wrote They actually aren't the same thing, heat spreaders do exactly what the name suggests, heatsinks however can be actively cooled by the case airflow and can show a significant change in temps between the two.

In terms of m.2 SSD "heat spreaders", yes they're the same thing. It's a sheet of metal that pulls heat away from the SSD. "Heat spreaders" can also be "actively cooled by case airflow" so long as it's making proper contact with the heat source.

M9z wrote ]The gap for my m.2's thermals is around 10c between two of the same models, so it definitely does make a difference

Different heat spreaders in different locations, yeah that doesn't surprise me that both drives aren't the exact same temp.

M9z wrote Also, m.2's are as fast as traditional SSD's, you're right there, but NVMe m.2's which this board supports do perform a bit better, and can also help performance on some games like Fallout 4 where storage speed does play a significant part due to it being a port and not that well optimized for PC, even using my NVMe there were a few mods I had to install to further help that particular issue resolve itself.

I didn't say NVMe wasn't better, I said it's a waste of $300+ to go with a 1TB 970 Pro if all OP is using the system for is gaming/streaming. A far cheaper NVMe SSD would perform more than adequately, and the extra money would make far more sense in a better GPU, which WILL actually show a noticeable improvement in performance for OP.


I decided to experiment, I had a heatsink on both boot and game drive. I put the spreader on the game drive and left the boot drive alone, game drive got hotter, I flipped them, and the temps changed again in favor of the heatsink. previously I was getting 34c on both with a heatsink on both, whichever drive I put a heat spreader on all of a sudden jumped by about 10c.

my control group I used was both m.2's with heatsinks registered 34c, same exact stress test using the spreaders registered 44c, using a mix of both heatsink on one and spreader on the other, swapping, then testing again, showed the exact results I expected. A proper heatsink with fins is more effective and most definitely not the same thing as a heat spreader.

#10. Posted:
21
  • Winter 2020
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 05, 201311Year Member
Posts: 16,215
Reputation Power: 3087
Motto: Me big smarts. Brainy boy do learns much
Motto: Me big smarts. Brainy boy do learns much
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 05, 201311Year Member
Posts: 16,215
Reputation Power: 3087
Motto: Me big smarts. Brainy boy do learns much
M9z wrote I decided to experiment, I had a heatsink on both boot and game drive. I put the spreader on the game drive and left the boot drive alone, game drive got hotter, I flipped them, and the temps changed again in favor of the heatsink. previously I was getting 34c on both with a heatsink on both, whichever drive I put a heat spreader on all of a sudden jumped by about 10c.

my control group I used was both m.2's with heatsinks registered 34c, same exact stress test using the spreaders registered 44c, using a mix of both heatsink on one and spreader on the other, swapping, then testing again, showed the exact results I expected. A proper heatsink with fins is more effective and most definitely not the same thing as a heat spreader.


Now remove them both entirely and tell me what temps you get.

In terms of an NVMe SSD, "heatsink" and "heat spreader" are often used to refer to the same type of product- it's a sheet of metal, with or without fins that is supposed to be used to aid cooling. Some don't work, some do, whether they have fins or not. What's important is that the heat source makes contact with the "heat spreader"/"heatsink", again, often used interchangeably in regards to NVMe SSD's.
Whether it's called a heat spreader, or heatsink, it's job is the same.

Although to be fair, yes, aftermarket ones with fins are typically going to be better than those included with motherboards, as they do typically have more surface area.
Users browsing this topic: None
Jump to:


RECENT POSTS

HOT TOPICS