#8561. Posted:
HTAFC
  • Christmas!
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 28, 201410Year Member
Posts: 1,801
Reputation Power: 94
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 28, 201410Year Member
Posts: 1,801
Reputation Power: 94
I really think Austin should have been in the team over Welbeck, the more goals in our strikers the better
#8562. Posted:
Sourc3gamer
  • Challenger
Status: Offline
Joined: Feb 26, 20159Year Member
Posts: 195
Reputation Power: 20
Status: Offline
Joined: Feb 26, 20159Year Member
Posts: 195
Reputation Power: 20
Senate wrote
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
CompleteDesigns wrote Am i the only one who thinks Joe harts performance wasent that special yesterday?

There was nothing wrong with his performance , You cant blame him for the defeat and he did just fine.

But for everyone to be going crazy of how well he played , I dont understand it.

Barca were great at cutting through Citys defence , But they were extremely poor when it came to taking the shots , A on game Barca would of destroyed them 5-0 and i dont care how good you think Joe hart is.

Like i said ,I think harts a decent keeper (And this isnt a Courtous / cech is better) etc.This is simply i dont think he played that well - If he let in any of the shots i think it would be labelled as a bad performance , The fact he saved them doesent make it a great performance , Just one you would expect from a PL level GK (Espically playing for city)

There was one save where i thought wow , thats a crazy save.The others were shots where if he let them in , Id be blaming him (If i was a city fan) as barca were awefull in front of goal , But had many chances.


Many of the saves showed that he is a great keeper.
I don't rate him highly in the prem, but he's currently Englands best gk.

- De Gea
- Courtois
- Cech
- Lloris
- Krul
- Hart

They'd be my top few, Hart being 6th


You'd put Krul in the top five. Where has that came from? he's more around the 10th mark.


Tim Krul has consistently shown he is a great goal keeper, unfortunately for him he is at a team that is not impeccable. He isn't near the top 4, but he's the 5th best in the league. I'd also say Forster, Guzan etc. are getting to a respectable level.


1. De Gea CS: 10 Saves Made: 79 Goals Conceded: 26
2. Lloris CS: 6 Saves Made: 94 Goals Conceded: 42
3. Courtois CS: 8 Saves Made: 55 Goals Conceded: 23
4. Hart CS: 9 Saves Made: 59 Goals Conceded: 24
5. Forster CS: 13 Saves Made: 61 Goals Conceded: 21
6. Cech CS: 0 Saves Made: 0 Goals Conceded: 0
7. Begovic CS: 7 Saves Made: 65 Goals Conceded: 35
8. Mingolet CS: 12 Saves Made: 62 Goals Conceded: 25
9. Krul CS: 7 Saves Made: 58 Goals Conceded: 30
10. Adrian CS: 6 Saves Made: 101 Goals Conceded: 37

imo

Krul hasnt really got the stats to compete with the top five. Yes he played well for holland but in the league he doesnt perform aswell as the others.
#8563. Posted:
Brad
  • Retired Staff
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 04, 201014Year Member
Posts: 5,770
Reputation Power: 530
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 04, 201014Year Member
Posts: 5,770
Reputation Power: 530
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
CompleteDesigns wrote Am i the only one who thinks Joe harts performance wasent that special yesterday?

There was nothing wrong with his performance , You cant blame him for the defeat and he did just fine.

But for everyone to be going crazy of how well he played , I dont understand it.

Barca were great at cutting through Citys defence , But they were extremely poor when it came to taking the shots , A on game Barca would of destroyed them 5-0 and i dont care how good you think Joe hart is.

Like i said ,I think harts a decent keeper (And this isnt a Courtous / cech is better) etc.This is simply i dont think he played that well - If he let in any of the shots i think it would be labelled as a bad performance , The fact he saved them doesent make it a great performance , Just one you would expect from a PL level GK (Espically playing for city)

There was one save where i thought wow , thats a crazy save.The others were shots where if he let them in , Id be blaming him (If i was a city fan) as barca were awefull in front of goal , But had many chances.


Many of the saves showed that he is a great keeper.
I don't rate him highly in the prem, but he's currently Englands best gk.

- De Gea
- Courtois
- Cech
- Lloris
- Krul
- Hart

They'd be my top few, Hart being 6th


You'd put Krul in the top five. Where has that came from? he's more around the 10th mark.


Tim Krul has consistently shown he is a great goal keeper, unfortunately for him he is at a team that is not impeccable. He isn't near the top 4, but he's the 5th best in the league. I'd also say Forster, Guzan etc. are getting to a respectable level.


1. De Gea CS: 10 Saves Made: 79 Goals Conceded: 26
2. Lloris CS: 6 Saves Made: 94 Goals Conceded: 42
3. Courtois CS: 8 Saves Made: 55 Goals Conceded: 23
4. Hart CS: 9 Saves Made: 59 Goals Conceded: 24
5. Forster CS: 13 Saves Made: 61 Goals Conceded: 21
6. Cech CS: 0 Saves Made: 0 Goals Conceded: 0
7. Begovic CS: 7 Saves Made: 65 Goals Conceded: 35
8. Mingolet CS: 12 Saves Made: 62 Goals Conceded: 25
9. Krul CS: 7 Saves Made: 58 Goals Conceded: 30
10. Adrian CS: 6 Saves Made: 101 Goals Conceded: 37

imo

Krul hasnt really got the stats to compete with the top five. Yes he played well for holland but in the league he doesnt perform aswell as the others.


Hart & Forster over Cech? lmao
#8564. Posted:
nice_gamer
  • TTG Addict
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 19, 201113Year Member
Posts: 2,037
Reputation Power: 1150
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 19, 201113Year Member
Posts: 2,037
Reputation Power: 1150
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
CompleteDesigns wrote Am i the only one who thinks Joe harts performance wasent that special yesterday?

There was nothing wrong with his performance , You cant blame him for the defeat and he did just fine.

But for everyone to be going crazy of how well he played , I dont understand it.

Barca were great at cutting through Citys defence , But they were extremely poor when it came to taking the shots , A on game Barca would of destroyed them 5-0 and i dont care how good you think Joe hart is.

Like i said ,I think harts a decent keeper (And this isnt a Courtous / cech is better) etc.This is simply i dont think he played that well - If he let in any of the shots i think it would be labelled as a bad performance , The fact he saved them doesent make it a great performance , Just one you would expect from a PL level GK (Espically playing for city)

There was one save where i thought wow , thats a crazy save.The others were shots where if he let them in , Id be blaming him (If i was a city fan) as barca were awefull in front of goal , But had many chances.


Many of the saves showed that he is a great keeper.
I don't rate him highly in the prem, but he's currently Englands best gk.

- De Gea
- Courtois
- Cech
- Lloris
- Krul
- Hart

They'd be my top few, Hart being 6th


You'd put Krul in the top five. Where has that came from? he's more around the 10th mark.


Tim Krul has consistently shown he is a great goal keeper, unfortunately for him he is at a team that is not impeccable. He isn't near the top 4, but he's the 5th best in the league. I'd also say Forster, Guzan etc. are getting to a respectable level.


1. De Gea CS: 10 Saves Made: 79 Goals Conceded: 26
2. Lloris CS: 6 Saves Made: 94 Goals Conceded: 42
3. Courtois CS: 8 Saves Made: 55 Goals Conceded: 23
4. Hart CS: 9 Saves Made: 59 Goals Conceded: 24
5. Forster CS: 13 Saves Made: 61 Goals Conceded: 21
6. Cech CS: 0 Saves Made: 0 Goals Conceded: 0
7. Begovic CS: 7 Saves Made: 65 Goals Conceded: 35
8. Mingolet CS: 12 Saves Made: 62 Goals Conceded: 25
9. Krul CS: 7 Saves Made: 58 Goals Conceded: 30
10. Adrian CS: 6 Saves Made: 101 Goals Conceded: 37

imo

Krul hasnt really got the stats to compete with the top five. Yes he played well for holland but in the league he doesnt perform aswell as the others.


You haven't included how many games he's played - before Pardew left Alnwick was regularly 1st choice, so the amount CS's/saves is less relevant than the CS/Saves to Game ratio.
#8565. Posted:
CompleteDesigns
  • TTG Fanatic
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 28, 201212Year Member
Posts: 4,076
Reputation Power: 182
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 28, 201212Year Member
Posts: 4,076
Reputation Power: 182
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
CompleteDesigns wrote Am i the only one who thinks Joe harts performance wasent that special yesterday?

There was nothing wrong with his performance , You cant blame him for the defeat and he did just fine.

But for everyone to be going crazy of how well he played , I dont understand it.

Barca were great at cutting through Citys defence , But they were extremely poor when it came to taking the shots , A on game Barca would of destroyed them 5-0 and i dont care how good you think Joe hart is.

Like i said ,I think harts a decent keeper (And this isnt a Courtous / cech is better) etc.This is simply i dont think he played that well - If he let in any of the shots i think it would be labelled as a bad performance , The fact he saved them doesent make it a great performance , Just one you would expect from a PL level GK (Espically playing for city)

There was one save where i thought wow , thats a crazy save.The others were shots where if he let them in , Id be blaming him (If i was a city fan) as barca were awefull in front of goal , But had many chances.


Many of the saves showed that he is a great keeper.
I don't rate him highly in the prem, but he's currently Englands best gk.

- De Gea
- Courtois
- Cech
- Lloris
- Krul
- Hart

They'd be my top few, Hart being 6th


You'd put Krul in the top five. Where has that came from? he's more around the 10th mark.


Tim Krul has consistently shown he is a great goal keeper, unfortunately for him he is at a team that is not impeccable. He isn't near the top 4, but he's the 5th best in the league. I'd also say Forster, Guzan etc. are getting to a respectable level.


1. De Gea CS: 10 Saves Made: 79 Goals Conceded: 26
2. Lloris CS: 6 Saves Made: 94 Goals Conceded: 42
3. Courtois CS: 8 Saves Made: 55 Goals Conceded: 23
4. Hart CS: 9 Saves Made: 59 Goals Conceded: 24
5. Forster CS: 13 Saves Made: 61 Goals Conceded: 21
6. Cech CS: 0 Saves Made: 0 Goals Conceded: 0
7. Begovic CS: 7 Saves Made: 65 Goals Conceded: 35
8. Mingolet CS: 12 Saves Made: 62 Goals Conceded: 25
9. Krul CS: 7 Saves Made: 58 Goals Conceded: 30
10. Adrian CS: 6 Saves Made: 101 Goals Conceded: 37

imo

Krul hasnt really got the stats to compete with the top five. Yes he played well for holland but in the league he doesnt perform aswell as the others.


That is the worst list i have seen in my life.

You obviously remember Cech is a class GK (You included him in top 6) but somehow place JOE HART and Forster over Cech?

So your telling me , If you had the chance of taking , Hart , Forster or Cech.

You would take Cech last? xD

He is still top 3 maybe 4 GKs in the prem , If it wasent for age (Still youngish for a GK) he would be number 1 IMO.Age factors mean De Gea and Courtois are over him , And maybe Lloris.
#8566. Posted:
Dive
  • 2 Million
Status: Offline
Joined: Apr 06, 201410Year Member
Posts: 2,156
Reputation Power: 95
Status: Offline
Joined: Apr 06, 201410Year Member
Posts: 2,156
Reputation Power: 95
CompleteDesigns wrote
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
CompleteDesigns wrote Am i the only one who thinks Joe harts performance wasent that special yesterday?

There was nothing wrong with his performance , You cant blame him for the defeat and he did just fine.

But for everyone to be going crazy of how well he played , I dont understand it.

Barca were great at cutting through Citys defence , But they were extremely poor when it came to taking the shots , A on game Barca would of destroyed them 5-0 and i dont care how good you think Joe hart is.

Like i said ,I think harts a decent keeper (And this isnt a Courtous / cech is better) etc.This is simply i dont think he played that well - If he let in any of the shots i think it would be labelled as a bad performance , The fact he saved them doesent make it a great performance , Just one you would expect from a PL level GK (Espically playing for city)

There was one save where i thought wow , thats a crazy save.The others were shots where if he let them in , Id be blaming him (If i was a city fan) as barca were awefull in front of goal , But had many chances.


Many of the saves showed that he is a great keeper.
I don't rate him highly in the prem, but he's currently Englands best gk.

- De Gea
- Courtois
- Cech
- Lloris
- Krul
- Hart

They'd be my top few, Hart being 6th


You'd put Krul in the top five. Where has that came from? he's more around the 10th mark.


Tim Krul has consistently shown he is a great goal keeper, unfortunately for him he is at a team that is not impeccable. He isn't near the top 4, but he's the 5th best in the league. I'd also say Forster, Guzan etc. are getting to a respectable level.


1. De Gea CS: 10 Saves Made: 79 Goals Conceded: 26
2. Lloris CS: 6 Saves Made: 94 Goals Conceded: 42
3. Courtois CS: 8 Saves Made: 55 Goals Conceded: 23
4. Hart CS: 9 Saves Made: 59 Goals Conceded: 24
5. Forster CS: 13 Saves Made: 61 Goals Conceded: 21
6. Cech CS: 0 Saves Made: 0 Goals Conceded: 0
7. Begovic CS: 7 Saves Made: 65 Goals Conceded: 35
8. Mingolet CS: 12 Saves Made: 62 Goals Conceded: 25
9. Krul CS: 7 Saves Made: 58 Goals Conceded: 30
10. Adrian CS: 6 Saves Made: 101 Goals Conceded: 37

imo

Krul hasnt really got the stats to compete with the top five. Yes he played well for holland but in the league he doesnt perform aswell as the others.


That is the worst list i have seen in my life.

You obviously remember Cech is a class GK (You included him in top 6) but somehow place JOE HART and Forster over Cech?

So your telling me , If you had the chance of taking , Hart , Forster or Cech.

You would take Cech last? xD

He is still top 3 maybe 4 GKs in the prem , If it wasent for age (Still youngish for a GK) he would be number 1 IMO.Age factors mean De Gea and Courtois are over him , And maybe Lloris.



I respect tech amazing keeper, would rank him 3rd would rather have him than Lloris.
#8567. Posted:
CompleteDesigns
  • TTG Fanatic
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 28, 201212Year Member
Posts: 4,076
Reputation Power: 182
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 28, 201212Year Member
Posts: 4,076
Reputation Power: 182
360MoTioN wrote
CompleteDesigns wrote
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
CompleteDesigns wrote Am i the only one who thinks Joe harts performance wasent that special yesterday?

There was nothing wrong with his performance , You cant blame him for the defeat and he did just fine.

But for everyone to be going crazy of how well he played , I dont understand it.

Barca were great at cutting through Citys defence , But they were extremely poor when it came to taking the shots , A on game Barca would of destroyed them 5-0 and i dont care how good you think Joe hart is.

Like i said ,I think harts a decent keeper (And this isnt a Courtous / cech is better) etc.This is simply i dont think he played that well - If he let in any of the shots i think it would be labelled as a bad performance , The fact he saved them doesent make it a great performance , Just one you would expect from a PL level GK (Espically playing for city)

There was one save where i thought wow , thats a crazy save.The others were shots where if he let them in , Id be blaming him (If i was a city fan) as barca were awefull in front of goal , But had many chances.


Many of the saves showed that he is a great keeper.
I don't rate him highly in the prem, but he's currently Englands best gk.

- De Gea
- Courtois
- Cech
- Lloris
- Krul
- Hart

They'd be my top few, Hart being 6th


You'd put Krul in the top five. Where has that came from? he's more around the 10th mark.


Tim Krul has consistently shown he is a great goal keeper, unfortunately for him he is at a team that is not impeccable. He isn't near the top 4, but he's the 5th best in the league. I'd also say Forster, Guzan etc. are getting to a respectable level.


1. De Gea CS: 10 Saves Made: 79 Goals Conceded: 26
2. Lloris CS: 6 Saves Made: 94 Goals Conceded: 42
3. Courtois CS: 8 Saves Made: 55 Goals Conceded: 23
4. Hart CS: 9 Saves Made: 59 Goals Conceded: 24
5. Forster CS: 13 Saves Made: 61 Goals Conceded: 21
6. Cech CS: 0 Saves Made: 0 Goals Conceded: 0
7. Begovic CS: 7 Saves Made: 65 Goals Conceded: 35
8. Mingolet CS: 12 Saves Made: 62 Goals Conceded: 25
9. Krul CS: 7 Saves Made: 58 Goals Conceded: 30
10. Adrian CS: 6 Saves Made: 101 Goals Conceded: 37

imo

Krul hasnt really got the stats to compete with the top five. Yes he played well for holland but in the league he doesnt perform aswell as the others.


That is the worst list i have seen in my life.

You obviously remember Cech is a class GK (You included him in top 6) but somehow place JOE HART and Forster over Cech?

So your telling me , If you had the chance of taking , Hart , Forster or Cech.

You would take Cech last? xD

He is still top 3 maybe 4 GKs in the prem , If it wasent for age (Still youngish for a GK) he would be number 1 IMO.Age factors mean De Gea and Courtois are over him , And maybe Lloris.



I respect tech amazing keeper, would rank him 3rd would rather have him than Lloris.


I was just saying , If i said he was over Llloris some may argue , Id personally put him over Lloris as well and id put him over Courtois and De gea if it wasent for age.

If i was a manager for a big team and i was building a team for the next few years , Id take De gea or Courtois.

But if i was looking for a GK to be consistent , A few years or a few matches or w/e id take Cech , I still think he is better than Courtois and De gea , Again the age factor makes the over 2 higher in the ranking (Though Cech is still quite young for a GK , Could go on for years)

I think its crazy how alot of people just forget about him though , Not long ago was the most consistent GK in the Prem.

Anyway on a side note , Apparently Mata to Valencia for 20M , I havent kept up with his performances , But surely he is worth 20M , Again another one of those players that was crazy good not long ago and now declined.

Id like him to go back to valencia and tear it up in the BBVA , Though i want him to stay in the BPL too.Should of stayed with us so bad xD.

Out of all the people who we sold he is easily the one i most regret . Even though i understand why.Imagine him playing with Fabregas and Costa in this team?
#8568. Posted:
Dive
  • V5 Launch
Status: Offline
Joined: Apr 06, 201410Year Member
Posts: 2,156
Reputation Power: 95
Status: Offline
Joined: Apr 06, 201410Year Member
Posts: 2,156
Reputation Power: 95
CompleteDesigns wrote
360MoTioN wrote
CompleteDesigns wrote
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
Sourc3gamer wrote
Senate wrote
CompleteDesigns wrote Am i the only one who thinks Joe harts performance wasent that special yesterday?

There was nothing wrong with his performance , You cant blame him for the defeat and he did just fine.

But for everyone to be going crazy of how well he played , I dont understand it.

Barca were great at cutting through Citys defence , But they were extremely poor when it came to taking the shots , A on game Barca would of destroyed them 5-0 and i dont care how good you think Joe hart is.

Like i said ,I think harts a decent keeper (And this isnt a Courtous / cech is better) etc.This is simply i dont think he played that well - If he let in any of the shots i think it would be labelled as a bad performance , The fact he saved them doesent make it a great performance , Just one you would expect from a PL level GK (Espically playing for city)

There was one save where i thought wow , thats a crazy save.The others were shots where if he let them in , Id be blaming him (If i was a city fan) as barca were awefull in front of goal , But had many chances.


Many of the saves showed that he is a great keeper.
I don't rate him highly in the prem, but he's currently Englands best gk.

- De Gea
- Courtois
- Cech
- Lloris
- Krul
- Hart

They'd be my top few, Hart being 6th


You'd put Krul in the top five. Where has that came from? he's more around the 10th mark.


Tim Krul has consistently shown he is a great goal keeper, unfortunately for him he is at a team that is not impeccable. He isn't near the top 4, but he's the 5th best in the league. I'd also say Forster, Guzan etc. are getting to a respectable level.


1. De Gea CS: 10 Saves Made: 79 Goals Conceded: 26
2. Lloris CS: 6 Saves Made: 94 Goals Conceded: 42
3. Courtois CS: 8 Saves Made: 55 Goals Conceded: 23
4. Hart CS: 9 Saves Made: 59 Goals Conceded: 24
5. Forster CS: 13 Saves Made: 61 Goals Conceded: 21
6. Cech CS: 0 Saves Made: 0 Goals Conceded: 0
7. Begovic CS: 7 Saves Made: 65 Goals Conceded: 35
8. Mingolet CS: 12 Saves Made: 62 Goals Conceded: 25
9. Krul CS: 7 Saves Made: 58 Goals Conceded: 30
10. Adrian CS: 6 Saves Made: 101 Goals Conceded: 37

imo

Krul hasnt really got the stats to compete with the top five. Yes he played well for holland but in the league he doesnt perform aswell as the others.


That is the worst list i have seen in my life.

You obviously remember Cech is a class GK (You included him in top 6) but somehow place JOE HART and Forster over Cech?

So your telling me , If you had the chance of taking , Hart , Forster or Cech.

You would take Cech last? xD

He is still top 3 maybe 4 GKs in the prem , If it wasent for age (Still youngish for a GK) he would be number 1 IMO.Age factors mean De Gea and Courtois are over him , And maybe Lloris.



I respect tech amazing keeper, would rank him 3rd would rather have him than Lloris.


I was just saying , If i said he was over Llloris some may argue , Id personally put him over Lloris as well and id put him over Courtois and De gea if it wasent for age.

If i was a manager for a big team and i was building a team for the next few years , Id take De gea or Courtois.

But if i was looking for a GK to be consistent , A few years or a few matches or w/e id take Cech , I still think he is better than Courtois and De gea , Again the age factor makes the over 2 higher in the ranking (Though Cech is still quite young for a GK , Could go on for years)

I think its crazy how alot of people just forget about him though , Not long ago was the most consistent GK in the Prem.

Anyway on a side note , Apparently Mata to Valencia for 20M , I havent kept up with his performances , But surely he is worth 20M , Again another one of those players that was crazy good not long ago and now declined.

Id like him to go back to valencia and tear it up in the BBVA , Though i want him to stay in the BPL too.Should of stayed with us so bad xD.

Out of all the people who we sold he is easily the one i most regret . Even though i understand why.Imagine him playing with Fabregas and Costa in this team?


Yeah I can see why you didn't want him to go, in form he is one of the best Cams in the world . I don't want him to leave as there's no point putting another player there as Mata is more than capable and is an amazing passer and scores a lot.
#8569. Posted:
Didact
  • V5 Launch
Status: Offline
Joined: May 12, 200915Year Member
Posts: 3,544
Reputation Power: 190
Status: Offline
Joined: May 12, 200915Year Member
Posts: 3,544
Reputation Power: 190
Just one of them isn't it, Everton. Hahahahaha.
#8570. Posted:
Fielding
  • Shoutbox Hero
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 19, 201212Year Member
Posts: 5,359
Reputation Power: 405
Status: Offline
Joined: Oct 19, 201212Year Member
Posts: 5,359
Reputation Power: 405
In a 4231,

De Gea
Valencia, Smalling, Rojo, Blind
Herrera , Carrick
Di Maria, Fellaini/Mata, Young
Rooney

Think that will be the team we will play, can see us drawing
Users browsing this topic: None
Jump to:


RECENT POSTS

HOT TOPICS