ShowcaseFirst go at a mascot logo
Posted:

ShowcaseFirst go at a mascot logoPosted:

Joyner
  • Graphics King
Status: Offline
Joined: Nov 29, 201112Year Member
Posts: 862
Reputation Power: 109
Status: Offline
Joined: Nov 29, 201112Year Member
Posts: 862
Reputation Power: 109
Usually I like to stick to my grungey social media designs such as headers that let me be as creative as possible with it still being pretty forgiving however I wanted to step out of my comfort zone and have a go at something that requires a more simplistic approach, therefore here is my first attempt at a mascot logo:
https://www.imageupload.net/upload-image/2020/01/11/ts-post.jpg

In hindsight I think I could've done the gas mask better but overall I'm happy with the results, criticism welcomed

The following 2 users thanked Joyner for this useful post:

16 (01-12-2020), RepBandit (01-11-2020)
#2. Posted:
16
  • Arcade King
Status: Offline
Joined: Nov 24, 201311Year Member
Posts: 3,673
Reputation Power: 12003
Status: Offline
Joined: Nov 24, 201311Year Member
Posts: 3,673
Reputation Power: 12003
I like the overall outcome, though my honest little quirks with the final are minor they could help out.

The good

  • Fluidity is really good if this is your first go at it, most people can't seem to pen the right way all the time. Kudos.
  • Scheme looks nice. Reminds me a little of how older mascot variations looked and were approached.
  • Good color palette but it could have a little less variation and focus more to blend. There is a little bit of a stark contrast in the outline to the mask. I would go similar but don't dilute.


The good but could use reworking

  • blurring on the bottom right/top left.
    • i would remove that and if you're blurring go more towards the edges that aren't directly in view.
    • Add some color into the background; the flat black looks nice as a contrast but is a bit too bland.

  • The glowing effect you went for shadows a bit too much from the eyes.
    • lower the shadow and just focus it a little more around eyes themselves.

  • The green outline is too thick. (preference) it is a little wide for what you were going for.
    • Thin the outline a little, this should result in a bit cleaner of a finished product.

  • Font decoration choice. This wasn't bad but it is a little reminiscent of pre-2014 mascot styling.
    • This one is completely artists choice, personally something a little more flowing/popping out at me and not so loosely spaced/sharp edged (i noticed you were lining the edges up to the shoulder width)
#3. Posted:
Joyner
  • Graphics King
Status: Offline
Joined: Nov 29, 201112Year Member
Posts: 862
Reputation Power: 109
Status: Offline
Joined: Nov 29, 201112Year Member
Posts: 862
Reputation Power: 109
Mitochondria wrote I like the overall outcome, though my honest little quirks with the final are minor they could help out.

The good

  • Fluidity is really good if this is your first go at it, most people can't seem to pen the right way all the time. Kudos.
  • Scheme looks nice. Reminds me a little of how older mascot variations looked and were approached.
  • Good color palette but it could have a little less variation and focus more to blend. There is a little bit of a stark contrast in the outline to the mask. I would go similar but don't dilute.


The good but could use reworking

  • blurring on the bottom right/top left.
    • i would remove that and if you're blurring go more towards the edges that aren't directly in view.
    • Add some color into the background; the flat black looks nice as a contrast but is a bit too bland.

  • The glowing effect you went for shadows a bit too much from the eyes.
    • lower the shadow and just focus it a little more around eyes themselves.

  • The green outline is too thick. (preference) it is a little wide for what you were going for.
    • Thin the outline a little, this should result in a bit cleaner of a finished product.

  • Font decoration choice. This wasn't bad but it is a little reminiscent of pre-2014 mascot styling.
    • This one is completely artists choice, personally something a little more flowing/popping out at me and not so loosely spaced/sharp edged (i noticed you were lining the edges up to the shoulder width)


Thanks a lot man, this is the in depth criticism that helps, luckily the blurring and eye effect where only on the actual post of the logo, the logo itswelf has neither, as for your other points they help a lot, so again thanks
#4. Posted:
Stressing
  • Blind Luck
Status: Online
Joined: Dec 20, 20149Year Member
Posts: 725
Reputation Power: 141
Status: Online
Joined: Dec 20, 20149Year Member
Posts: 725
Reputation Power: 141
wow that is nice
#5. Posted:
Pish
  • Christmas!
Status: Offline
Joined: Jun 25, 20159Year Member
Posts: 993
Reputation Power: 109
Status: Offline
Joined: Jun 25, 20159Year Member
Posts: 993
Reputation Power: 109
Mitochondria wrote I like the overall outcome, though my honest little quirks with the final are minor they could help out.

The good

  • Fluidity is really good if this is your first go at it, most people can't seem to pen the right way all the time. Kudos.
  • Scheme looks nice. Reminds me a little of how older mascot variations looked and were approached.
  • Good color palette but it could have a little less variation and focus more to blend. There is a little bit of a stark contrast in the outline to the mask. I would go similar but don't dilute.


The good but could use reworking

  • blurring on the bottom right/top left.
    • i would remove that and if you're blurring go more towards the edges that aren't directly in view.
    • Add some color into the background; the flat black looks nice as a contrast but is a bit too bland.

  • The glowing effect you went for shadows a bit too much from the eyes.
    • lower the shadow and just focus it a little more around eyes themselves.

  • The green outline is too thick. (preference) it is a little wide for what you were going for.
    • Thin the outline a little, this should result in a bit cleaner of a finished product.

  • Font decoration choice. This wasn't bad but it is a little reminiscent of pre-2014 mascot styling.
    • This one is completely artists choice, personally something a little more flowing/popping out at me and not so loosely spaced/sharp edged (i noticed you were lining the edges up to the shoulder width)



It has been soooo long since I have such a beautiful critique. One of the reasons I stopped posting on here.

Bravo
#6. Posted:
Ghost
  • Graphics King
Status: Offline
Joined: Jun 15, 201410Year Member
Posts: 13,769
Reputation Power: 15670
Motto: Did somebody say "Just Eat"
Motto: Did somebody say "Just Eat"
Status: Offline
Joined: Jun 15, 201410Year Member
Posts: 13,769
Reputation Power: 15670
Motto: Did somebody say "Just Eat"
I love to color scheme and unique Design, learning to designs mascot logos myself.
Users browsing this topic: None
Jump to:


RECENT POSTS

HOT TOPICS