Apple wins court order blocking U.S. sale of Samsung Galaxy Nexus

4.3
A U.S. District Court has handed Apple a victory against one of its biggest competitors in the smartphone market by blocking U.S. sales of the Samsung Galaxy Nexus.

U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh granted Apple a preliminary injunction against the Galaxy Nexus phone, which went on sale in the United States in mid-December.

This is the second Samsung Galaxy product blocked by Koh this week: On Tuesday, she granted Apple a preliminary injunction against U.S. sales of the Galaxy Tab 10.1 tablet computer.

Koh granted the injunction after Apple argued that the Galaxy Nexus phone caused it irreparable harm due to long-term market-share loss and "losses of downstream sales," according to The Next Web.

Reuters reporter Dan Levine described the scene in the courtroom after the injunction was granted: The lawyer representing Samsung, John Quinn, had a long face, and Apple's attorney Mike Jacobs was smiling.

"It's no coincidence that Samsung's latest products look a lot like the iPhone and iPad, from the shape of the hardware to the user interface and even the packaging," an Apple spokeswoman said in an email. "This kind of blatant copying is wrong and, as we've said many times before, we need to protect Apple's intellectual property when companies steal our ideas."

Neither Samsung nor Google responded to a request for comment.

[Updated, June 29, 5:20 p.m.: Google emailed a response regarding the preliminary injunction. "We're disappointed with this decision, but we believe the correct result will be reached as more evidence comes to light," the company said.]

[For the record, June 29, 5:15 p.m.: An earlier version of this post incorrectly said the Galaxy Nexus phone began selling in the U.S. in late April. In fact, it went on sale in the U.S. in mid-December through Verizon. The Google Play store began selling it in late April.]

Posted:

Source: http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-apple-samsung-galaxy-nexus-20120629,0,5421074.story

Comments

"Apple wins court order blocking U.S. sale of Samsung Galaxy Nexus" :: Login/Create an Account :: 91 comments

If you would like to post a comment please signin to your account or register for an account.

GLOCK-PERFECTIONPosted:

Hmm maybe hackers such as anonymous need to hack apple. May let apple know their not untouchable.

BritishColumbiaPosted:

Cant believe Apple did this

Spectrum3kPosted:

Honestly everyone has there own opinion. I totally agree that apple makes a superior mobile product considering how popular the istore is, but I do not like apple as a company. All this said is that people are ignorant and find every thing possible to claim copyright on. Im sure something could of been worked out or apple could of been like if you simply just remodel certain parts it would be fine, BUT NO apple is becoming a mobile marketing monopoly and is trying to basically limit competitors so that you will be forced to buy an iphone or ipad. Believe me they make a great product, but between the ipad and galaxy tab they are meant some different uses. Such as a Galaxy tab can use programs straight from your windows of course with proper installation and codec. The ipad can only offer so much that does not come in an app unless you jailbreak it and forfeit your factory warranty. Though this is a bit ironic considering you idiots who think you know everything cannot admit that your wrong or do not know..... There were touchscreens BEFORE the ipod touch, iphone, and ipad. So lets not get carried away and say apple came up with everything. NOT TO MENTION HOW DID APPLE BEGIN --- A PARTNER WITH BILL GATES WHO TOOK Mr. GATES IDEAS..... and do not say it is not true unless you know your facts because that CERTAIN PERSON actually admitted it on public TV. yes, i do not mention his name because I do not judge apple as a company now by ones disloyalty...

DubblePosted:

Im a samsung person not an apple one and this is just stupid, apple are feeling threatened by samsung because of samsungs success with the galaxy so they are trying to hurt their company. Its simply out of order

SovietRussiaPosted:

I'm going to say they are starting a monoply

DICE-Posted:

crazyxxsniperxx44
DICE-
FPS_Ryan Thats what you get for not being original Samsung.


That is funny because Apple is doing a lot of copying these days, such as the notification bar, mobile wallet app, Twitter and Facebook integration, having a camera on the lock screen, voice commands(was in Froyo which came out in 2010) and these are just a few of the things that iOS has clearly taken from Android, and these all came from Android. Apple is not original at all, they just sue all of the Android phone makers because they can't compete with Android.


wtf are you talking about voice commands. It's not copying its called improvements and if that is the case well then i guess Tom Clancys End War is copying to because they use voice commands. Same with the Xbox 360 Kinect, its not copying voice commands is a feature no one owns. You're just another idiot who can't get over Apple being more successful than you and all of your descendants combined.


I was saying that Apple takes ideas from others and markets it as their own. They did not come up with Siri, they purchased the company that developed it. Yes, they are improving voice commands, but they did not come up with the idea of voice commands on smart phones, see what I am getting at here?

TiltPosted:

Apple always wins!

crazyxxsniperxx44Posted:

DICE-
FPS_Ryan Thats what you get for not being original Samsung.


That is funny because Apple is doing a lot of copying these days, such as the notification bar, mobile wallet app, Twitter and Facebook integration, having a camera on the lock screen, voice commands(was in Froyo which came out in 2010) and these are just a few of the things that iOS has clearly taken from Android, and these all came from Android. Apple is not original at all, they just sue all of the Android phone makers because they can't compete with Android.


wtf are you talking about voice commands. It's not copying its called improvements and if that is the case well then i guess Tom Clancys End War is copying to because they use voice commands. Same with the Xbox 360 Kinect, its not copying voice commands is a feature no one owns. You're just another idiot who can't get over Apple being more successful than you and all of your descendants combined.

BritishColumbiaPosted:

wait cant apple just be like give me %5 of each one sold or something, like how Motorola wants Microsoft to do

thePiManxPosted:

here is what the judge is basically saying.

"you people are so stupid that i need to protect you. you cant tell an apple product from a samsung product."

look at the pictures on google and see if the Nexus looks like and iphone.
where is the ONE button that the iphone has? hmm? no where.

the UI, seriously? i dont even know where to start on that one.

that judge is an idiot.