The projects, known as re3 and reVC, were essentially pre-Definitive Edition(opens in new tab) updates aimed at getting the older GTA games running properly on modern hardware, with some bug fixes and new features like widescreen support. Take-Two originally had them removed from Github using a DMCA takedown notice, but they were restored after a counter-claim by the developers. Take-Two responded to that maneuver with a copyright infringement lawsuit, saying the mod makers "sought unlawfully to copy, adapt, and distribute to the public infringing source code" to Grand Theft Auto 3 and Vice City.
The lawsuit noted not only the allegedly infringing nature of the mods themselves, but also the actions that the named modders took to get around the DMCA takedown request: "In at least three separate instances between April and June of 2021, Defendants Orçunus, Morra, and Graber submitted sworn counter notifications to GitHub claiming the takedown of the repositories was mistaken or otherwise not legitimate. Take-Two is informed and believes, and on that basis alleges, that these counter notifications were made in bad faith, and knowingly and deliberately misrepresented to GitHub the contents of the re3 GitHub Repositories."
Not much happened after that, according to TorrentFreak(opens in new tab), until December 2022, when both parties requested that materials in the discovery portion of the lawsuit be exempted from public disclosure because they were likely to contain confidential or proprietary information. Word of a potential settlement followed shortly thereafter, and then on April 3, after multiple delays, the request to dismiss the lawsuit(opens in new tab) was filed.
The suit was dismissed with prejudice, which means it cannot be re-filed, but it was only dismissed against the four named defendants: The lawsuit also named 10 John Does as defendants, and the filing noted specifically that "the remaining defendants are not dismissed by this stipulation."
In an update(opens in new tab) filed the next day, however, Take-Two also dismissed the case against those defendants, but without prejudice, meaning it can re-file the action against them. One of the John Doe defendants is noted as "Ash R. and Ash_735," which is presumably Ash_735 on Twitter(opens in new tab): They retweeted the settlement filing earlier this week.
Take-Two did not indicate whether a settlement was reached with the mod makers or why it dismissed the lawsuit, but it's possible that the release of officially updated versions of GTA3 and Vice City—despite the very rough shape(opens in new tab) they were in when they launched—have simply made it redundant. I've reached out to Take-Two for comment and will update if I receive a reply.
Case closed against the modders behind re3 and reVC, following an out of court settlement reached earlier today. In case you forgot, those were the reverse engineering projects for GTA III and VC that T2 DMCA'd and sued over. https://t.co/ZoaneQRvTy
— Badger G. 🦡 (@BadgerGoodger) April 4, 2023
Posted:
Related Forum: PC Gaming Forum
Source: https://www.pcgamer.com/take-two-dismisses-lawsuit-against-grand-theft-auto-modders/
"Take-Two dismisses lawsuit against Grand Theft Auto modders" :: Login/Create an Account :: 2 comments