Xbox One lacks proper storage management; MS says it is 'automatic'

4.7
Microsoft will ship the Xbox One to customers on Friday with a built in 500GB hard drive that's been designed not to be removed or upgraded. At first, the company announced that the console would support adding external storage but later said the feature would not be available for launch.

Now the first reviews of the Xbox One have come in and they have confirmed that the console will not allow owners to view just how much useable storage space is available on the hard drive. Eurogamer's review of the console states:

"With Forza 5 and Ryse installed to the hard drive, in addition to a number of other review titles, our concern now is all about storage management. Here's where things get a little strange. As far as we can tell, there is no storage overview to tell you how much hard drive space remains or allow you to delete items in one centralized location. There also appears to be no direct access to save games, either - these and game DVR upload clips appear to be synced with the cloud. It's interesting that in what is the most ambitious console operating system ever produced, the user seems more remote than ever from content."




It's a feature that's available on the Xbox 360, as shown above, and Sony's PlayStation 4 also has a way to view how much free space is left on its 500GB hard drive.

Neowin contacted Microsoft to ask why the Xbox One lacks a traditional storage viewing or management features. We received a response from a Microsoft spokesperson:

"Xbox One was designed to make storage management automatic. For saved games, settings, and other information that Xbox One customers save to the cloud, space is virtually unlimited. On the internal hard drive in each Xbox One, games and apps can be uninstalled or reinstalled instantly with the click of the Xbox One menu button. Saved games and settings information is retrieved from the cloud for any game as its being reinstalled. By being smart about how storage is managed, Xbox One keeps everyone playing, watching, and sharing their entertainment content rather than worry about limitations. You can also see how much storage any app uses by pressing the menu button on that app."


The bottom line is that people who get their console on Friday will not have a direct way to know if that long awaited game they are installing on their hard drive will be able to fit alongside all the other games and content they have already saved. Considering that some Xbox One launch titles have large install footprints, up to 43GB in one case, that could be a big problem in the near future.

Posted:
Related Forum: Xbox Forum

Source: http://www.neowin.net/news/xbox-one-lacks-proper-storage-management-microsoft-says-it-is-automatic

Comments

"Xbox One lacks proper storage management; MS says it is 'automatic'" :: Login/Create an Account :: 56 comments

If you would like to post a comment please signin to your account or register for an account.

-CPPosted:

That will be quite a pain....

TrainzboyPosted:

That just makes me wonder... How will offline gameplay work? If all gamesaves are saved in the cloud...
Well, there's a bit of an issue there, huh?
(Yeah, I really haven't been studying up on how the One works... :/ )

MPAAPosted:

LaserShow Yeah.. Now that I think about it. I don't think I have ever checked how much space is left on my XBox 360 drive. I just play my XBox and forget about such details. Which is why I bought an Xbox in the first place, to be able to play games without having to manage it like a PC. Maybe Microsoft noticed this practice among users.


They should still let the more techy users have access, I get pissed off with this one size fits all attitude that Steve Ballmer seems to have

MinneapolisPosted:

Its an easy fix through an update dont get your panties in a bundle

BackbonePosted:

People shouldn't be too bothered about this because a minor issue like this could easily be added in an update

BRSPosted:

raefon Yes it seems a strange feature to leave out. Ever since the Dos day you could check how much storage space you had on any given median.

Why not have the option it seems like simple logic.




I was under the belief that the xboxone directly in this case was supposed to be the all around entertainment experience?

need to know how much drive space you have if you plan to play your music through it... drive space utility is a must!

BRSPosted:

Yeah.. Now that I think about it. I don't think I have ever checked how much space is left on my XBox 360 drive. I just play my XBox and forget about such details. Which is why I bought an Xbox in the first place, to be able to play games without having to manage it like a PC. Maybe Microsoft noticed this practice among users.

MPAAPosted:

Dreams i think it was fine the way it was before not a fan of the cloud and would much rather have it how it is now


Agreed. I believe its to push users to use the SkyDrive service, rather than the modding rumour, I dont even mod so they better reverse this stupid move. Does the PS4 give you any freedom in this field? if not that would explain why PC gaming is getting more popular than ever.

TrevorPosted:

i dont see how anybody can complain about the 500 gb of space i mean honestly who is going to feel up 500 gigs on launch by the time you get to where you need extra space they should have the external storage available

TopNotchKiNGPosted:

This is Microsoft's feeble attempt to stop the most harmless of modding, savegame mods. Savegame mods 9/10 times only affect the actual user of the mods and they usually only work in Single Player which is local only and doesn't affect the online community at all. Call of Duty WAW and a few others are excluded because there Savage mods do affect online but the game is over 5 years old so it shouldn't be a big issue. Modding is fun, players want to have fun after they've beaten the game.