modiction wrote Battle field 3 has been nominated as one of the best online multiplayer games in the world. so basically you should know to get live to play online. But for the people who dont have live the multiplayer isnt at all that fun. To start you cant even play multiplayer so if you dont have live throw that multiplayer co-op disc in the trash because you wont be needing it. Me personally wouldnt have bought the game if I didnt have xbox live because the only thing you can do without live is play the campaign, which isnt very hard to complete. So if you think battlefield 3 looks totally amazing! but if you dont have xbox live dont buy it, unless ofcourse your into playing maybe i dont know 10 or 12 missions over and over again. Without xbox live or a ps3 to play online with, it sucks, period.

Hmmmm.. sounds to me that you either
A: Play RPG's like Skyrim or that sort
or
B: You're a CoD fanboy trying to cause trouble.
My best guess is its A because I doubt you would be talking about Battlefield 3 like this if you had CoD because most people get both games for the multiplayer gameplay anyway.

Am I right?

If you bought a game for the multiplayer, why don't you buy live?