Xbox One 'employs advanced troll detection'

4.4
The Xbox One will have a number of new measures designed to ensure that anyone cheating or being abusive online won't ruin things for those playing fairly.

In an interview with Official Xbox Magazine, Microsoft's senior product manager Mike Lavin explained how a new reputation system and cloud support will both work together to ensure those who play by the rules will have a better experience.

While Party Chat will remain an option in Xbox One, Lavin says that Microsoft hopes more people will want to play online games while communicating with strangers, and that "in order to do that, you need a community of folks that aren't screaming vulgarities every ten seconds, or the griefers or the harassers, those types of folks."

According to Lavin, the new reputation system, which replaces the five-star system currently used on Xbox 360, means that "ultimately if there's a few per cent of our population that are causing the rest of the population to have a miserable time, we should be able to identify those folks."

He went on to suggest that players with similar reputations will be more likely to face each other during matchmaking.

"So there'll be very good things that happen to people that just play their games and are good participants. And you'll start to see some effects if you continue to play bad or, or harass other people en masse. You'll probably end up starting to play more with other people that are more similar to you."

Lavin was also quick to make it clear that players won't be able to deliberately reduce someone's reputation by getting a group of friends to give them negative feedback all at once.

"Let's just be clear, there is no way at all that a conglomerate of people can conspire to sink your Reputation on the system," he said.

"The way that it's built fundamentally stops that. It's very much over a period of time. If we see consistently that people, for instance, don't like playing with you, that you're consistently blocked, that you're the subject of enforcement actions because you're sending naked pictures of yourself to people that don't want naked pictures of you... blatant things like that have the ability to quickly reduce your reputation score."

The new reputation system aside, Lavin also claimed the Xbox 360's cloud support will also help prevent some players from cheating during games, since it will enable more developers to run their games from a dedicated server instead of resorting to direct player-to-player connections.

"I've read on forums that there a lot of assumptions that people are screwing around with their routers for some games and trying to gain unfair advantages," he explained. "We are dead set against cheating in every capacity, and we continue to make investments to root those folks out.

"Because we're offering all of this free compute power to Xbox One game creators, we're really advocating for server-based hosting. You're going to see a lot of that in Forza - Forza Motorsport 5 is server-based, so it kind of eliminates the ability to screw with your router and give the other person an unfair advantage.

"We believe that en masse, as people take advantage of our cloud compute offerings, that we should start to see a major drop in that problem, with player-hosted multiplayer."

Posted:
Related Forum: Xbox Forum

Source: http://www.computerandvideogames.com/417545/xbox-one-employs-advanced-troll-detection/

Comments

"Xbox One 'employs advanced troll detection'" :: Login/Create an Account :: 156 comments

If you would like to post a comment please signin to your account or register for an account.

imgurPosted:

Well this should be an interesting concept. They should focus on more serious exploits though...

lugiaisbeast101Posted:

Oasis
lugiaisbeast101
Oasis
DeadMouse This won't work.. lol and + people hardly use the feedback thing


I use it all the time. And plenty of people I know do too.

It will work because it's giving some of the responsibility to a computer to figure out people that are being annoying. I'm sure serious matters will still be dealt with by me employees. Like threats, sexual abuse and so on.


You are then forgetting that there are many children and teenagers on these systems and play games that are not appropriate to their age. In saying this, these children just completely refuse to lose, and when a person comes along that's far superior to that individual, that individual will use that feedback method in a way not intended. Yes it will be good, but many will do what I just stated to the superior individuals in a game that play it for a living.


If you'd have read the article you would have seen the part about the misuse of the feedback system. Meaning that not one persons opinion of you will affect your rating, rather many opinions over a long time in many different scenarios will. Just as you say, if a person i.e. quits early numerous times, then the system will notice without you doing anything, in turn making better matches for you in the future.

It's not a day one fix, it's a system that will grow over time and learn peoples habits. Hopefully for the better for everyone.


Yes, thank you for pointing that out, but I assure you that I've read the article before I've posted. I'm just making a point, multiple people can misuse this system in many different ways, I just gave one scenario. One person is far superior in a game then the average players, and when that player shows his skill, many will give negative feedback towards him giving that player even worse match ups thereon, when maybe that person actually wants to play against someone of his skill level. Either way, this will be abused and I'm not to keen on the idea.

AustraliansPosted:

gowaddict trolling is funny if they ban you for it then thats just sad


No it's not, they aren't exactly talking about blocking you in a corner trolling, something serious like kicking you offline or ruining your Minecraft world for no damn reason xD

SorceryPosted:

Alone
gowaddict trolling is funny if they ban you for it then thats just sad


Not all trolling is funny, like when some kids made a 10 year old do loads of stuff to get money to change his name then they just told him he's not in their clan. That's just harsh.


To be honest 10 year old kids shouldn't be speaking to people on Xbox Live anyway, blame the parents for not using Family Settings.

MurderersPosted:

hell yeah im so happy this is gonna be awesome

DoGoodPosted:

This is a very good idea on M$ part

AlonePosted:

gowaddict trolling is funny if they ban you for it then thats just sad


Not all trolling is funny, like when some kids made a 10 year old do loads of stuff to get money to change his name then they just told him he's not in their clan. That's just harsh.

EG6Posted:

ShadowBoltDashie
RaheemSterling_31 I find it sad reporting someone, unless they are like hacking on a game like cod and you can't kill them.

Reporting someone for trolling is sad though.


For trolling yeah. But if they are like getting people's IP and reading it off in the lobby reporting them is fine.


I have to agree with you on that one. Its the same on PS3. I was beating some kid on league so at the end of the first round he read out my IP then said goodbye and I got signed out.

TaigaAisakaPosted:

RaheemSterling_31 I find it sad reporting someone, unless they are like hacking on a game like cod and you can't kill them.

Reporting someone for trolling is sad though.


For trolling yeah. But if they are like getting people's IP and reading it off in the lobby reporting them is fine.

LWRPosted:

I find it sad reporting someone, unless they are like hacking on a game like cod and you can't kill them.

Reporting someone for trolling is sad though.