You are viewing our Forum Archives. To view or take place in current topics click here.
Mustang vs. Challenger vs. Camaro...
Posted:

Mustang vs. Challenger vs. Camaro...Posted:

392
  • TTG Undisputed
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 13, 201410Year Member
Posts: 5,592
Reputation Power: 61
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 13, 201410Year Member
Posts: 5,592
Reputation Power: 61
So as you guys know 4 days ago the engine on my Buick went that I had for almost 3 years as my starter car. My family has decided it's time to replace the car rather than continue to put money into it. My family refuses to allow anything non-american in their driveway lol So I'm torn between a Mustang, Challenger, and Camaro all of which are cars I have an appreciation for. I would also appreciate it if you guys can make some recommendations based on experience or what you guys know about each car. Maybe just list some pros and cons and what you like or dislike to help me out, thanks guys
#2. Posted:
Rob
  • Shoutbox Elite
Status: Offline
Joined: Jan 29, 201113Year Member
Posts: 1,599
Reputation Power: 23816
Status: Offline
Joined: Jan 29, 201113Year Member
Posts: 1,599
Reputation Power: 23816
First off all 3 of these cars depending on what engine, model, color, etc will have high insurance payments and if you are a younger male that also makes your insurance go higher, so I would call your insurance and compare rates on all 3 models you're interested in that way you know exactly what youll be paying for insurance. Also depends on what year of those cars your looking at, and brand new or used?

Me personally, would not purchase a ford. It would be between the dodge and Chevy. My decision between those two would depend on what model/year you're interested in. You can't ever go wrong with a Chevy I'll tell you that.. I own a 2016 impala ltz and I love the car hasn't given me a single problem what so ever. Challenger is also a good car but it would really depend on the year/model if I was the one purchasing. Personally I would not purchase a v6 model of any of these cars only the v8 models interest me. Good luck to you in finding the right vehicle! Feel free to pm me if you'd like to give me a bit more info and I can help you out more.
#3. Posted:
002
  • Summer 2023
Status: Offline
Joined: Sep 25, 201410Year Member
Posts: 4,817
Reputation Power: 7349
Status: Offline
Joined: Sep 25, 201410Year Member
Posts: 4,817
Reputation Power: 7349
Without any information I'm going with a brand new base model.

Dodge is owned by Fiat so the Challenger is no longer American. American in design, but Italian by ownership.

I know the Camaro used to be built in Canada since the 90's until last year when they were talking about building it in America again, I'm not sure if they are or not though.

That leaves the Mustang as the most American muscle car out of the the three.

The Dodge is the slowest of the 3, and the Camaro is straight up unusable compared to the others. Visibility is horrendous and the trunk is almost laughable. I would say the Mustang is the funnest to drive as it's lighter, has more space and has slightly better visibility.
#4. Posted:
392
  • TTG Undisputed
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 13, 201410Year Member
Posts: 5,592
Reputation Power: 61
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 13, 201410Year Member
Posts: 5,592
Reputation Power: 61
Ganga wrote First off all 3 of these cars depending on what engine, model, color, etc will have high insurance payments and if you are a younger male that also makes your insurance go higher, so I would call your insurance and compare rates on all 3 models you're interested in that way you know exactly what youll be paying for insurance. Also depends on what year of those cars your looking at, and brand new or used?

Me personally, would not purchase a ford. It would be between the dodge and Chevy. My decision between those two would depend on what model/year you're interested in. You can't ever go wrong with a Chevy I'll tell you that.. I own a 2016 impala ltz and I love the car hasn't given me a single problem what so ever. Challenger is also a good car but it would really depend on the year/model if I was the one purchasing. Personally I would not purchase a v6 model of any of these cars only the v8 models interest me. Good luck to you in finding the right vehicle! Feel free to pm me if you'd like to give me a bit more info and I can help you out more.
my insurance drops this year and why not a ford?
#5. Posted:
002
  • Rigged Luck
Status: Offline
Joined: Sep 25, 201410Year Member
Posts: 4,817
Reputation Power: 7349
Status: Offline
Joined: Sep 25, 201410Year Member
Posts: 4,817
Reputation Power: 7349
Zombae wrote
Ganga wrote First off all 3 of these cars depending on what engine, model, color, etc will have high insurance payments and if you are a younger male that also makes your insurance go higher, so I would call your insurance and compare rates on all 3 models you're interested in that way you know exactly what youll be paying for insurance. Also depends on what year of those cars your looking at, and brand new or used?

Me personally, would not purchase a ford. It would be between the dodge and Chevy. My decision between those two would depend on what model/year you're interested in. You can't ever go wrong with a Chevy I'll tell you that.. I own a 2016 impala ltz and I love the car hasn't given me a single problem what so ever. Challenger is also a good car but it would really depend on the year/model if I was the one purchasing. Personally I would not purchase a v6 model of any of these cars only the v8 models interest me. Good luck to you in finding the right vehicle! Feel free to pm me if you'd like to give me a bit more info and I can help you out more.
my insurance drops this year and why not a ford?


If he says get a V8 over a V6, the reason he says not to get a Ford is because he's a Chevy fan boy. No one on this forum has enough knowledge or has had enough cars to be able to say X brand is good or bad. All they can say is they had luck with X brand X model X year. A 2016 Impala is not a 2017 Camaro and would not be driven the same.
#6. Posted:
Rob
  • Shoutbox Elite
Status: Offline
Joined: Jan 29, 201113Year Member
Posts: 1,599
Reputation Power: 23816
Status: Offline
Joined: Jan 29, 201113Year Member
Posts: 1,599
Reputation Power: 23816
002 wrote
Zombae wrote
Ganga wrote First off all 3 of these cars depending on what engine, model, color, etc will have high insurance payments and if you are a younger male that also makes your insurance go higher, so I would call your insurance and compare rates on all 3 models you're interested in that way you know exactly what youll be paying for insurance. Also depends on what year of those cars your looking at, and brand new or used?

Me personally, would not purchase a ford. It would be between the dodge and Chevy. My decision between those two would depend on what model/year you're interested in. You can't ever go wrong with a Chevy I'll tell you that.. I own a 2016 impala ltz and I love the car hasn't given me a single problem what so ever. Challenger is also a good car but it would really depend on the year/model if I was the one purchasing. Personally I would not purchase a v6 model of any of these cars only the v8 models interest me. Good luck to you in finding the right vehicle! Feel free to pm me if you'd like to give me a bit more info and I can help you out more.
my insurance drops this year and why not a ford?


If he says get a V8 over a V6, the reason he says not to get a Ford is because he's a Chevy fan boy. No one on this forum has enough knowledge or has had enough cars to be able to say X brand is good or bad. All they can say is they had luck with X brand X model X year. A 2016 Impala is not a 2017 Camaro and would not be driven the same.



For one, please do not call me a "boy" I'm 22 years old. For two, I ain't no Chevy fan boy. I simply gave him my opinion on what he asked, nothing more... yes I've owned a total of 8 Chevrolets in my time of driving one of which I ran all the way up to 325k miles so you can understand why I may be bias to a Chevy. Also, i do not see the point in buying a muscle car to get a v6 engine, again my opinion. Now a v8 does not suit everyones budget or preference, I understand that... this is just MY opinion..
#7. Posted:
392
  • TTG Undisputed
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 13, 201410Year Member
Posts: 5,592
Reputation Power: 61
Status: Offline
Joined: Jul 13, 201410Year Member
Posts: 5,592
Reputation Power: 61
Ganga wrote
002 wrote
Zombae wrote
Ganga wrote First off all 3 of these cars depending on what engine, model, color, etc will have high insurance payments and if you are a younger male that also makes your insurance go higher, so I would call your insurance and compare rates on all 3 models you're interested in that way you know exactly what youll be paying for insurance. Also depends on what year of those cars your looking at, and brand new or used?

Me personally, would not purchase a ford. It would be between the dodge and Chevy. My decision between those two would depend on what model/year you're interested in. You can't ever go wrong with a Chevy I'll tell you that.. I own a 2016 impala ltz and I love the car hasn't given me a single problem what so ever. Challenger is also a good car but it would really depend on the year/model if I was the one purchasing. Personally I would not purchase a v6 model of any of these cars only the v8 models interest me. Good luck to you in finding the right vehicle! Feel free to pm me if you'd like to give me a bit more info and I can help you out more.
my insurance drops this year and why not a ford?


If he says get a V8 over a V6, the reason he says not to get a Ford is because he's a Chevy fan boy. No one on this forum has enough knowledge or has had enough cars to be able to say X brand is good or bad. All they can say is they had luck with X brand X model X year. A 2016 Impala is not a 2017 Camaro and would not be driven the same.



For one, please do not call me a "boy" I'm 22 years old. For two, I ain't no Chevy fan boy. I simply gave him my opinion on what he asked, nothing more... yes I've owned a total of 8 Chevrolets in my time of driving one of which I ran all the way up to 325k miles so you can understand why I may be bias to a Chevy. Also, i do not see the point in buying a muscle car to get a v6 engine, again my opinion. Now a v8 does not suit everyones budget or preference, I understand that... this is just MY opinion..
Buying a v6 muscle car would mean cheaper insurance by up to a few grand, and better gas mileage while still having the same roar a muscle car has rather than a fart can exhaust a ricer has
#8. Posted:
LagCausesRage
  • Challenger
Status: Offline
Joined: Mar 24, 201113Year Member
Posts: 167
Reputation Power: 6
Status: Offline
Joined: Mar 24, 201113Year Member
Posts: 167
Reputation Power: 6
002 wrote Without any information I'm going with a brand new base model.

Dodge is owned by Fiat so the Challenger is no longer American. American in design, but Italian by ownership.

I know the Camaro used to be built in Canada since the 90's until last year when they were talking about building it in America again, I'm not sure if they are or not though.

That leaves the Mustang as the most American muscle car out of the the three.

The Dodge is the slowest of the 3, and the Camaro is straight up unusable compared to the others. Visibility is horrendous and the trunk is almost laughable. I would say the Mustang is the funnest to drive as it's lighter, has more space and has slightly better visibility.

lol if you're buying any of these cars for their trunk space you're an idiot also you're wrong about weight.. Camaro is the lightest out of all of them.
#9. Posted:
LagCausesRage
  • V5 Launch
Status: Offline
Joined: Mar 24, 201113Year Member
Posts: 167
Reputation Power: 6
Status: Offline
Joined: Mar 24, 201113Year Member
Posts: 167
Reputation Power: 6
Really depends what you want. I personally own a 2013 Camaro SS. Im not sure how much you're looking to spend or what body style you like better out of all of them blah blah blah. Anyways from personal experience i can tell you that i absolutely love my Camaro. the biggest pro about a V8 Camaro is that from years 98+ they have the LS based engines which are just about the most reliable engine you can get from a performance car. Also if you are into cars and like to build them up the LS engines have one of the biggest aftermarkets there is. parts are relatively cheap and they make good power. If you're not too much into cars then you still cant really go wrong with a Camaro. Stock they have enough power to make you smile and wow you. Plus the LS engines still get about 20+mpg. Dodge isn't bad either. I don't know as much about the Dodges but usually from what i hear its about a 50/50 shot if you will like it or not. Mustangs I personally don't like. Not my taste. A Mustang will probably be your cheapest option. Dodge will most likely be the most expensive.
#10. Posted:
Z06
  • TTG Addict
Status: Offline
Joined: Feb 27, 201212Year Member
Posts: 2,819
Reputation Power: 357
Status: Offline
Joined: Feb 27, 201212Year Member
Posts: 2,819
Reputation Power: 357
Ganga wrote
002 wrote
Zombae wrote
Ganga wrote First off all 3 of these cars depending on what engine, model, color, etc will have high insurance payments and if you are a younger male that also makes your insurance go higher, so I would call your insurance and compare rates on all 3 models you're interested in that way you know exactly what youll be paying for insurance. Also depends on what year of those cars your looking at, and brand new or used?

Me personally, would not purchase a ford. It would be between the dodge and Chevy. My decision between those two would depend on what model/year you're interested in. You can't ever go wrong with a Chevy I'll tell you that.. I own a 2016 impala ltz and I love the car hasn't given me a single problem what so ever. Challenger is also a good car but it would really depend on the year/model if I was the one purchasing. Personally I would not purchase a v6 model of any of these cars only the v8 models interest me. Good luck to you in finding the right vehicle! Feel free to pm me if you'd like to give me a bit more info and I can help you out more.
my insurance drops this year and why not a ford?


If he says get a V8 over a V6, the reason he says not to get a Ford is because he's a Chevy fan boy. No one on this forum has enough knowledge or has had enough cars to be able to say X brand is good or bad. All they can say is they had luck with X brand X model X year. A 2016 Impala is not a 2017 Camaro and would not be driven the same.



For one, please do not call me a "boy" I'm 22 years old. For two, I ain't no Chevy fan boy. I simply gave him my opinion on what he asked, nothing more... yes I've owned a total of 8 Chevrolets in my time of driving one of which I ran all the way up to 325k miles so you can understand why I may be bias to a Chevy. Also, i do not see the point in buying a muscle car to get a v6 engine, again my opinion. Now a v8 does not suit everyones budget or preference, I understand that... this is just MY opinion..


Hi boy

And as statistics show the v6 of any of those vehicles are bought more then their v8 counterpart

Cheaper insurance, dodge offers awd for their v6 versions, just as good because most people dont care for 400-700hp which is where all those cars fall into for the v8, plus maintenance is a lot cheaper, and it goes on so there is a point to then, you're just being a lil bit of a fan boy
Jump to:
You are viewing our Forum Archives. To view or take place in current topics click here.